The East River, separating Manhattan from Queens and Brooklyn, is many things, but river is not one of them. Basically speaking, it’s a sunken valley. Realistically speaking, it’s a sewer.
By David Stone
Assorted Ideas, Large & Small/Special to the Roosevelt Island Daily
The East River Over Time
Born over 2.5 billion years ago, the East River came into being as a sunken valley carved out of the last ice age. As glaciers shrunk north, melt off forced sea levels to rise. Salt water filling up areas around present day New York City created a tidal strait, this one unusually pushed and pulled by three sources.
A huge factor in turning the East into an open sewer are the triple forces entering the waterway from the Atlantic Ocean, the Harlem River — also not a river — and Long Island Sound. The East changes direction as frequently as every two hours with the power of the current changing too. That’s a novelty, a curiosity, but it also wipes out its ability to flush itself. Conflicting tides block whatever’s in the water from clearing out efficiently.
A range of solutions have been offered, the most useful being a damn at the western end of the Long Island Sound. That would allow a more natural flushing, coordinated with the Ocean. But the trouble always is money. Nobody is willing to spend enough, and that also contributes to the failure of other solutions floating around.
Mired in the 19th Century, Flooded with Failure
Living on Roosevelt Island with a view facing Manhattan, I’ve been long aware that the stories told about stormy weather overflows into rivers, straits and canals were incomplete. Under clear blue skies on a summer day, water gushed into the East River, visible above the waterline at low tide. But that never squared with the official story.
“Every time it rains in New York, millions of gallons of sewage-laced stormwater flows into the city’s waterways. Instead of being diverted to a wastewater treatment plant, what goes down your toilet ends up floating along rivers, canals, beaches, and waterfront parks. All told, more than 20 billion gallons of feces-polluted water is flushed out onto the city’s coastline every year.”
Waste water systems for New York, built in the mid-1800s, did not anticipate today’s population density. And at the time, the worst damage came from factories and plants on the shorelines. They dumped wastes directly into the water untreated because the ocean is vast. It could absorb all those chemicals not yet recognized as toxic.
And then, there is this…
That’s how the East River got hurt in the first place, but increasingly, a prime contributor was whatever went down your sink, bathtub and toilet. The conversion to sewage removal by municipal pipes from that of men carting it away from outhouses overnight increased convenience. It also delivered untreated human wastes into the water.
Feeble water treatment efforts, according to NYC Department of Environmental Protection numbers, now allow 11 billion gallons of human waste into various city waterways every year. But no one’s counting the unexplained releases like the one shown above. They contradict the official story, releasing who knows what into the river.
A Perspective on the East River
Roosevelt Island is unique because it sits in the middle of the East River, witnessing raw sewage outflows from both Queens and Manhattan. Along with Manhattan gushers, we get four more sewage releases between Astoria and Queensbridge Parks.
The trouble, of course, is that nobody really knows the full effects of being surrounded periodically by raw sewage. Take a walk around the Roosevelt Island shoreline on a good day. You won’t see the East River’s bottom at a depth of more than a foot. The water is too foul, already. On a stormy day, it’s worse.
The local community is not alone, but it may serve as a general example. Nobody ever discusses evaporates rising out of the water. Or contaminates brought out by steady ship traffic. Asthma, recurring headaches and other potential, less apparent long term risks are certainly at play. And not on anyone’s official radar.
Do not expect any improvement. In early 2020, the National Resources Defense Counsel (NDRC) severely panned a remediation plan put forward by DEP. After seven years of study, the city agency came up with a method of eliminating only 2% of the wastes. Even at best, it allows 11.5 billion gallons pouring into NYC waterways, including the East River.
That leaves the sunken valley an open sewer for years, probably decades ahead.
More from Assorted Ideas, Large & Small
The East River is not a true river. It’s really a sewer.
The East River, separating Manhattan from Queens and Brooklyn, is many things, but river is not one of them. Basically speaking, it’s a sunken valley. Realistically speaking, it’s a sewer. By David […]
What’s Killing Hawks, Owls, Ducks and Squirrels in New York City Parks?
Katie Honan, THE CITY This article was originally publishedon Oct 18 at 7:37pm EDTby THE CITY/Sign up here to get the latest stories from THE CITY delivered to you each morning. The dead, male, red-tailed hawk […]
New York City Views — Fraternal Twins, 2nd Avenue & 59th Street
More from Assorted Ideas, Large & Small
New York Skyline, Early Autumn Sunset in FDR Four Freedoms State Park
In FDR Four Freedoms State Park, the most serene space in all five boroughs, an early autumn sunset outlines the New York skyline. So near while still so far away… Also from […]
“Nothing Crushes Us…” True. One Year Ago in Greenwich Village
“Nothing Crushes Us,” a poster on University Place in Greenwich Village, a sign of New York City unity. Outdoor dining was just beginning to get a foothold, and a year later, it […]
Not just Billy Joel, everyone’s in a New York State of Mind. Listen.
NYCNext corrals the best New York City voices, from rap to Broadway, across the spectrum, in a New York State of Mind… singing celebration of love. I’ve literally got nothing to add. […]